Sisyphus’s Boulder: Why Do We Keep Returning to the Same Place?

Hanzade Acar
February 5, 2026

Written by Oprah Winfrey and Dr. Ania Jastreboff, Enough moves the conversation about weight beyond discussions of willpower and reframes it through the lenses of biology, brain mechanisms, and social prejudice. The book argues that obesity is not a character flaw, but a scientific and human reality connected to the right to live in one’s own body without guilt.

Sometimes you read a book and do not simply learn something new; you realize that everything you thought you knew about yourself, every story you have been telling yourself until that moment, may have been based on a misconception. You take a deep breath and think, “Oh.”

Enough, currently climbing toward the top of the New York Times Best Seller list and holding the third position, is exactly that kind of book.

Written by media icon Oprah Winfrey and Dr. Ania Jastreboff of Yale School of Medicine and published by Avid Reader Press / Bluebird, this book may appear to promise a discussion about weight and health. Yet hidden within its pages is what is essentially a human rights issue: the right to live in our own bodies without feeling guilty.

History’s Misconceptions: Hysteria, Corsets, and the Myth of Willpower

Throughout history, human beings have tended to label every biological condition they could not understand as a “character problem.”

Let us go back to the nineteenth century, to the Victorian era.

At that time, doctors attributed many of the physical and emotional struggles experienced by women to an invented condition they called “hysteria.” And what was the treatment? Often isolation. Sometimes shock treatments involving ice-cold water. Sometimes simply the pressure to “control your emotions.”

Today, we know that many of those women were actually experiencing biological, neurological, or hormonal imbalances. But whenever medicine looked for someone to blame, the finger always pointed toward the individual’s supposedly weak willpower or flawed character.

Think about the famous corsets of that same era, used to force the body into shape. Those tight garments that crushed ribs and restricted breathing—were they merely fashion accessories?

No.

They were the price of becoming an “acceptable” person, of demonstrating self-control, of fitting into society’s expectations. You had to fit the mold, even at the cost of being unable to breathe.

Perhaps we removed those fabric corsets long ago, but we replaced them with something far more dangerous: mental corsets.

For years, we were taught the following:

“If you can’t lose weight, it’s because you lack willpower. You simply don’t want it badly enough.”

That belief is one of the most merciless corsets ever placed around the modern human spirit.

Oprah’s Red Wagon and Sisyphus’s Boulder

In the book, Oprah openly shares the period in her life when willpower felt most difficult.

Many people may remember the moment. In 1988, Oprah appeared on her television show pulling a red wagon containing 67 pounds of animal fat. She had survived for months on a liquid diet, essentially starving herself, and presented the weight she had lost as a symbol of victory.

“Look,” she said. “I did it.”

But what happened next?

As soon as she returned to a “normal” pattern of eating, her biology fought back. She regained all the weight she had lost and more.

That red wagon was not the symbol of a triumph.

It was the symbol of a tragic misunderstanding.

It reminds me of Sisyphus from Greek mythology the king condemned to push an enormous boulder uphill, only to watch it roll back down every time he reached the summit, repeating the cycle forever.

Aren’t the millions of people who spend years dieting, beginning every Monday with the promise that “this time it will work,” only to be defeated by the gravity of their own biology and return to the starting point, the modern-day Sisyphuses of our age?

A “Pasteur Moment” for Science: The Real Problem Is Not the Person, but Biology

Dr. Jastreboff and Oprah discuss another parallel from medical history.

Before Louis Pasteur and Robert Koch developed and demonstrated germ theory, people believed disease resulted either from personal weakness or from bad air the so-called miasma theory.

And what was the solution?

Blame the patient.

Make them feel ashamed.

But the moment science declared, “No, this is not a character flaw. This is a germ,” shame ended and treatment began.

According to the book, we are experiencing that same moment of enlightenment in the field of obesity today.

The message is simple:

This is not about willpower.

This is about biology.

How Long Can You Hold Your Breath Underwater?

At the center of the book is an explanation for why Sisyphus’s boulder keeps rolling back down the hill.

The authors call it The Enough Point.

Deep within our brains operates a thermostat-like mechanism programmed to protect our body weight and fat levels.

When we diet and attempt to move below that level, the body interprets the situation as famine.

When the temperature drops in your home, the thermostat activates the heating system.

The brain does something similar. It slows metabolism and increases appetite.

Its goal is to return you to your previous weight.

Dr. Jastreboff explains this through a powerful metaphor:

“Trying to lose weight through willpower is like holding your breath underwater. You can do it for a while. If you are especially strong, you can do it for a little longer. But eventually your biology takes over and forces you to breathe.”

Those moments when you believed you were weak.

Those moments when you hated yourself for eating that piece of cake.

Those moments were not failures of willpower.

They were victories by your biology, trying to keep you alive.

The Miranda Priestly Living Inside Our Brains: Food Noise

Why is it sometimes so difficult to say “enough”?

The book gives a name to an experience many people live with but struggle to describe:

Food Noise.

It reminded me of The Devil Wears Prada.

Do you remember Miranda Priestly, the cold, demanding editor portrayed by Meryl Streep?

Never satisfied.

Always wanting something else.

Making impossible demands in the middle of the night.

Constantly occupying your mind.

Living with food noise is like living with a Miranda Priestly inside your head.

You are in a meeting.

Playing with your child.

Watching a movie.

Yet somewhere in the background, a voice keeps talking:

“What are we going to eat next?”

“You should have finished that.”

“What’s for dinner?”

“No, don’t eat that. Eat this.”

“You ate too much again.”

This endless internal dialogue functions like a black hole, pulling in a person’s joy, imagination, and ability to remain present.

Many people call it gluttony.

But in reality, it is an obsession that never stops spinning through the mind.

Oprah describes it this way:

“For years, there was a radio station constantly playing in my head, and I assumed everyone lived like that.”

Silence Begins to Speak, and a New Path Opens

This is where the book and perhaps this era’s greatest “aha” moment arrives.

When Oprah began the new treatment journey recommended by her doctor, including the next-generation therapies described in detail throughout the book that help restore hormonal balance, she did not define the experience as “losing weight.”

She described it as silence and freedom.

Oprah recalls:

“One morning I woke up, and the first thing I thought about wasn’t what I was going to eat for breakfast. It was silence.”

Her stomach did not shrink.

Her willpower did not become stronger.

The noise simply stopped.

The Miranda Priestly inside her mind finally went quiet.

For the first time, she could look at the food in front of her and say:

“I don’t need this. This is enough.”

And she did not say it through struggle.

Not by gritting her teeth.

Not by fighting herself.

She said it because she genuinely felt it.

The medical approach discussed in the book is not a shortcut or a trick.

A person with poor eyesight wearing glasses is perfectly normal.

Likewise, a person whose brain’s satiety signals their internal thermostat setting are malfunctioning should be able to receive support without shame.

The issue is not becoming thin.

The issue is freeing the mind from captivity and creating space to live up to one’s true potential.

Why Should You Read It?

Enough is not only for people who want to lose weight.

It is a book for anyone who finds themselves struggling with themselves in any area of life.

Because the greatest gift it offers is compassion.

Think about the harsh words you have said to yourself while looking in the mirror over the years.

“Why can’t I do this?”

“Why can’t I be like everyone else?”

This book invites you to embrace the reflection staring back at you and say:

“The problem was never your character.”

“The problem was never your spirit.”

“Your thermostat was simply set incorrectly.”

Now adjust that setting.

Turn down the noise.

And perhaps, for the first time in your life, say clearly:

“This is enough.”

This book is the first step toward that freedom.

 

Link : https://www.forbes.com.tr/forbes-life/sisyphus-un-kayasi-neden-hep-ayni-yere-donuyoruz